Saturday, October 4, 2025

An overview of Amy Bennett's work


I stumbled across this new video of a lecture by Amy Bennett overviewing her work soon after I posted my diorama and micro-layout design notes where I mentioned her work was an inspiration. The entire video is worth watching, but she has some particularly interesting insights into HO scale and lighting. As well, there are many interesting quotes, but for diorama-ists this one is particularly insightful: "But I never try to accurately recreate a place. Reality is just a jumping off point. It's much more fun to be loose and responsive to the model making process."

Thursday, October 2, 2025

Design notes on bases for dioramas and micro-layouts

Base for Moon Mail Madness diorama after Cell-U-Clay had hardened.

I thought I’d spend a little time writing down my thoughts on how bases for dioramas and micro-layouts should be designed; well, maybe I should back off a bit and say these notes are about how I like to design bases. I think about this topic from time-to-time and it popped into my mind again after participating in the recent scale model show held here so I figured maybe this was a good time to put some notes together. I don’t claim any originality or universality here. No doubt many modellers have gone down this road too and touched on many of the same ideas. I can’t say that these notes apply to all situations; your mileage may vary :-)

I used the models to sketch on a big sheet of paper how each would be positioned on the base.

Ok, let’s move on to the first topic. These notes aren’t in any particular order, just what pops into my head as I write.

The arrangement went through several iterations; this one is close to the final

Inspiration: MacRae, Smith, Bennett, Adams, + ...

To me a diorama isn’t just a few objects or figures set on a base to show off a model in a more favourable light as implied by the show’s flyer, which noted that for their purposes we’re looking at a diorama when the following condition is met: “As soon as ANY [JDL: All caps theirs] objects are added to the bases other than the model, it will be classed as a “diorama””. To me a diorama, in the context of scale model work, isn’t simply a collection of objects, but is a model display that tells a story. The story is the primary feature and the models support the telling. A few objects or figures on a base accompanying a model isn’t a diorama, it’s simply a way of displaying a model to best advantage.

From time-to-time eye level views were assessed as the arrangement was iterated.

I’m much inspired by the dioramas of Bruce MacRae, especially his Wine Tasters diorama, as well as the scenes constructed by Michael Paul Smith, Amy Bennett, and Kim Adams. 

Now the work of Smith and Bennett aren’t dioramas in the sense that scale modellers use. Smith created what could be considered temporary scenes for purposes of photographing them, and the temporary scenes Bennett builds are for creating paintings from. However, the key here is they both use models to create scenes that tell stories. 

The objects Kim Adams makes are closer to that of classic model making diorama-ists, but the content of his work is very different. His stories are often ones of exploration into alternative possibilities of our physical world, not just highly detailed reflections of it.

But, the connecting thread running through the work of all four artists is that the centre of interest in their dioramas isn’t one or two particularly well detailed models, but stories. 

Scraps of foam sheet to be used to make the base.

In the model railroading world, E. L. Moore is my main influence. Not everything he built centred on a story, but a lot did. Over the last few years I've been impressed by the layouts shown in the French magazine Voie Libre. Ok, yes, this has an air of shameless self-promotion since a few photos of the Loonar Module appeared there in 2023 in a micro-layout feature, but in my defence I submitted photos there for a couple of reasons. I was impressed by the small layouts they'd written about over the previous 3 or 4 years, and I had never seen a layout set in a Canadian scene by an actual Canadian in their pages! I wanted to fix that injustice :-) The rest is history :-)

I quite enjoy all the layouts Voie Libre has featured, but I especially like the work of Bernard Junk and Detlev Horn, notably their layout called The Island.

Continental Modeller is also a good place to see innovative layouts. And, yes, yes, more shameless self-promotion, the Centennial Experimental Farm layout appeared in its pages this year. 

All I'm saying is that there's a lot of interesting work going on in the wide world of model railroad layouts

Tracing template was cut out after finalizing the arrangement.

Shape: Base Shape Helps Story

The footprints of many dioramas and small layouts are simple geometric shapes: squares, rectangles, circles, and ovals. This is quite understandable as these are readily obtainable in the form of pieces of wood, picture frames, display plaques, and so on. I’ve come to think though that the footprint should help tell the diorama’s story.

Sometimes foam sheets were glued together to make suitably sized pieces

I didn’t really understand this when I built the Loonar Module. I used 2’ x 2’ by 1” thick insulating foam sheets for the base because they were easy to buy at the local home renovation store. But, I wound up building a round island on a square lake! It turned out ok, but if there’s a next time the base’s footprint will reflect the story since water isn’t square :-)

Later, when I was building the Centennial Experimental Farm layout I could have just gone ahead with a rectangular footprint for the base, but I thought it more appropriate for the base to be rectangular at the Carling road end since the road was all straight edges, and rounded at the streetcar return loop at the farm end. There it matched the graceful loop of the track, and didn’t present dead corners to be filled in as it would if this end was also square. So, curved lines at the natural end, and straight edges at the urban end.

A layer ready for cutting out with a hand saw and knife.

The Mt. Lowe layout is where I’ve really started to apply the ’base shape helps story’ principle. Mt. Lowe had several scenes that I wanted to capture, but they had to be somewhat separated from each other. The trefoil seemed to help realize that desire with its three prominent lobes, each providing a separate scenic area. Thinking about the trefoil’s scenic potential a bit more I realized its footprint actually allows for 7 scenes: the 3 lobes, the 3 concavities connecting the lobes, and the aerial view, which in this case is a mountain top observatory.

Lots of scraps and foam dust after cutting out the pieces.

With the Moon Mail Madness diorama I took the principle further. As you can see in this post’s photos I designed the base’s shape as I used the models to sketch out the story; both developed at the same time. And what is the story? It’s a slice of life in the lunar postal service: two lunar postal workers meet at a crossroads and one takes a photo of the other as he begins to remove letters from a mailbox :-) I thought the base’s footprint should match the shape of the road intersection to emphasize the crossing. Also, why make the base square or rectangular and have to deal with dead space that needs filling? The only external limit on the footprint was the show’s specified requirement that all dioramas had to fit in a 2’ x 2’ area, not be a 2’ x 2’ area, which was no problem fulfilling.  

White glue holds the stack together. A rasp and sanding blocks used to form the final shape.

Presence: A Subtle Call to Look

Over the years I’ve come to like thick bases for dioramas and small layouts. 

A lot of dioramas and small layouts I’ve seen present the viewer with a decent top side model and scene set on a thin, platter-like base. Sort of like a meal that has been put on a dinner plate. Some might say, well it’s the modelling that’s of interest and not what it’s sitting on, much like it’s the meal that’s important and not the plate below.

An anti-slip mat was cut and glued to the bottom of the base.

To me though a diorama or layout is a complete, integrated object; a type of three-dimensional sculpture. A diorama doesn’t consist of a good part (the model work) that is to be enjoyed and an irrelevant support part (the base) that is to be ignored. The base’s footprint helps to tell the story, and its height helps to command you to look at that story by establishing the diorama or layout’s physical presence amongst all other objects that vie for a viewer’s attention.

This is another idea that at first I didn’t fully appreciate. The Loonar Module’s base is 3 foam sheets thick because I wanted it to be quite rigid and strong. Mission accomplished. However, looking at the result over weeks and months I felt the thick base gave the layout a solid look that I quite liked. It seemed like the island actually was rooted in something, not just sitting on something.

Anti-slip mat trimmed to fit the bottom of the base.

On the Centennial Experimental Farm I deliberately made the base height about the same as what I thought the tallest tree would be. It seemed odd to me to have big, tall trees (completely to scale regarding height and canopy volume) sticking out of a base no thicker than a pizza box. It didn’t seem balanced. It didn’t seem substantial.

However, like the Loonar Module’s base, I painted it black because I didn’t want the base to draw attention to itself. Its job was simply to say “here’s a story” and bring it to a viewer’s attention, not be the story. The base is to be the strong silent type component in this object we call a diorama: it provides structural support, it’s footprint provides narrative support, it’s height makes a call for attention and visually balances the models, but it tries to do all this in a subtle manner, not calling unnecessary attention to itself. 

The mailbox rise is glued to the base. Note commercial vac-formed crater to the right.

Moon Mail Madness violates the subtly principle a little with the inclusion of the postcard. I thought it would help the overall story, and it tries to be subtle while doing so. Sometimes on layouts that are structured like framed paintings instead of sculptural objects you’ll see a lot of labels, stickers, photos, warnings, awards, and other ephemera attached to the surround. That’s all too loud and distracting for me. The layout needs to speak for itself. Likewise, dioramas need to speak for themselves. They shouldn’t need any supporting documentation or ephemera hanging around trying to divert attention.

Crater glued on. White glue spread on foam prior to applying Cell-U-Clay.

Materials: Sheet Foam

I use foam sheets for my bases because they are lightweight, strong when laminated, easy to cut and shape, and low cost. I learned a hard lesson when I built the portable Lost Ocean Line layout from wood. It became too heavy to be very portable by me alone. Other materials can certainly be used. Foam sheets aren’t some magic one-size-fits-all solution, but I’d say put the wood back in the rack if it isn’t completely necessary. If you’re using wood for decorative reasons, that’s a different story.

Spare Moonscope wheel was used to roll in tracks.

On the Loonar Module I sided the base with sheet styrene to give it a smooth finish. I’ve subsequently learned that isn’t completely necessary. Smoothing the foam sides and then painting them with an artist’s quality acrylic will produce a decent finished surface. Although foam sides may seem a bit rough and soft after shaping and smoothing, the acrylic paint acts as a binder to solidify the surface as well as provide colour. Think of the paint job as applying a surface binder that just so happens to have a colour, which is black in my case. 

After 2 weeks of curing, cheap acrylic paints were used to colour the surface

Eye Level: An unresolved problem

I’ve always thought that the conventional way scale models (plastic models, train layouts, doll houses, every category really) are shown and displayed is odd. I think the best way to view them is at eye level because, usually, that’s how we encounter their real life counterparts. Yet, models are usually displayed so that the most common viewing angle is from above. I understand the practical reasons for this, but it doesn’t do justice to the models and the work of their makers. By setting out models on tables of conventional height only small children get the best views :-) 

Maybe conventional tables augmented with some sort of leg extensions would do the trick for model shows. Combined with showing dioramas or layouts with thick bases, this might almost solve the eye level viewing problem. Or maybe not. If you’re a long time reader here I’ve tried some experiments to fix this issue over the years, but haven’t been satisfied yet with the results. 

Ready for adding the models.

These aren't likely my final thoughts on the subject. They simply capture a few aspects of my current thinking. 

Oh, and before I run off for coffee, Sheperd Paine's book How to build Dioramas is always good to consult. Maybe I'll dive in again while coffee's brewing.

Awaiting the show.

Wednesday, October 1, 2025

The utility passenger car is ready to roll!

 It didn't take much more work to add a bench and canopy to the flat car. 


All the framework is styrene and I think the photo tells all about how it was built. The canopy itself is cut from a piece of vellum. 


The canopy frame has a bit of a crazy twist to it, but when it's rolling along the layout it looks right at home, twist and all.

Monday, September 29, 2025

A model railroader goes to a plastic scale model show

My 'Moon Mail Madness' diorama. (No, that tattooed leg isn't mine) 

I went to the scale model show held at the Holland Armoury on Sunday. Ok, well, I did more than go, I entered a diorama too. The first time I've entered one of these events since 1975 at age 15.

When I heard about the show back in June I immediately had an idea for a diorama after reading the requirements on the show's flyer. I had some vehicles I had kitbashed back in 2005 or so that had never been entered into a show before, and now I had some impetus to build the diorama I long thought they belonged on. The small layouts I've built over the last few years have improved my diorama modelling skills, so it seemed like the right time to give this project a go.

The blue car on the left is a 'Martian Rover' I kitbashed from an AMT/ERTL Dodge Deora Show Car kit.


The box was shortened by 1", and the roof forward of the back window frame was cut off. The wheels and tires are from an AMT/ERTL Moonscope kit. I was kind of obsessed with the Moonscope kit back then and its parts showed up in a lot of my builds. However, I did build one up and mildly accessorized it:


The trailer is from an AMT/ERTL Fireball 500 kit. And yes, the wheels and tires are from another Moonscope kit.


The postal vehicle on the trailer is a very old MPC Ultravan kit that has been accessorized - yes, you guessed it, accessorized with some Moonscope parts :-)


The mailbox is a new build. It's made from scrap pieces of sheet styrene. The prototype is the mailbox at the end of my street. The door handle needed to be big so a gloved astronaut could grab it. Keeping in line with the show's theme of 100 Years of Mopar the handle is from a '69 Dodge Charger!


I'll do a separate post on building the base, but for now I'll note that it's built up from Cell-U-Clay.

Your loyal scribe shows off his handy work.

A bit of paint, a bit of glue, and a postcard from someone's mum and everything is ready to go.


So, off I went. 

You know I had great expectations for the dioramas that I might encounter. I waffled for a long time about taking mine as in the grand scheme of things I didn't spend a lot of time on it even though it was a fun little project.

This is the passage in the show's promotional flyer that sent my thoughts racing:

"*Models may have bases. As soon as ANY objects are added to the bases other than the model, it will be classed as a "diorama" *Dioramas cannot exceed 2' x 2' (51cm x 51cm)"

Seems an innocuous statement, but it got me thinking two things: first, I thought show dioramas must be becoming such large, complex pieces that practical limits had to be placed on entrants (which got me thinking my little diorama would be massively overshadowed), and, second, when 2' x 2' was noted I immediately started to think they should have a category for micro-layouts. You may recall 2' x 2' was the footprint for the Loonar Module micro-layout. Look, in essence all a micro-layout is, is a diorama with an element capable of motion. Why are there segregated shows for plastic models, especially ones that are components of large dioramas, and shows for model trains? It's likely just a historical relic whose root has something to do with how the hobby business was and still is structured. I think there'd be some interesting opportunities for idea sharing if big dioramas with plastic models and micro-layouts could share a show. Let's not forget micros, and many smaller sized, portable layouts can be in larger scales like 1/64, 1/48, 1/35, 1/32, 1/24, and 1/22.5, which correspond with several plastic model scales. Not too mention that a few micros have featured automobiles, military themes, and airplanes as well as trains. 

There were only 3 dioramas featuring automobiles - at least when I was there*

Who won you might ask? It wasn't me and I don't know who did. *I had to leave early due to a comedy of errors I caused that was ignited by lost keys :-( It ended with the keys found and a bout of leaf raking. I'll say no more.

Main diorama table at red arrow. Impressive work that I unfortunately didn't capture.

There was lots of impressive work on display and I was very glad to have attended to see it all. The one project that made the biggest impression was this one (unfortunately I don't know who to credit this build to, but if you're out there, you did a great job!):

I entered one of these kits in the 1975 model show.

Why? You remember that 1975 model show I mentioned entering, well, it was one of these kits that I built and entered. I didn't paint it up like this (I didn't have the skill), or build it anywhere near as good, but I'd recognize it anywhere.

Ah, memories.

Monday, September 22, 2025

Making a start on a utility passenger car

The 'passenger' car is simply a flat car with a bench. Here's the flat car part. Bench is still to come.

On-and-off over the past few weeks I've made a start on a very simple, open air passenger car for the Mt. Lowe layout. It's based on one I saw a plan for in this book:

This is one of the best RR books I've read. Highly recommended!

The Portage Railway, aka the Hunstville and Lake of Bays Transportation Company, was a narrow gauge railway that ran in Huntsville, Ontario from 1904 to 1959 and not in California's San Gabriel Mountains as did the Mt. Lowe railway. Strangely though, I don't have a problem with that. For this little layout I think this Ontario vintage, barebones people hauler - the so-called 'canopied inspection wagon' that is basically a bench on a flatcar with a canopy above - stylistically fits in with the overall scene. Plan 7 in the book's drawings section spells out the configuration and dimensions. 

A peek at the book's drawing as I work out dimensions

Two changes I plan to make to the car are: 1) change the height of the bench above the flat car's floor, and 2) make the canopy's supports a little less flimsy. The bench's seat seems a little low and the canopy looks like it would blow off in a light breeze, so both of these will be changed once I start work on passenger accommodations. 

For now though, the task at hand is building the basic flat car.

Based on a Peco NR-122 wagon chassis

I'm basing this project on a Peco N-scale wagon chassis kit; it's their so-called 15' wheelbase steel type chassis, kit # NR-122. I had bought a couple of these kits a long time ago to try my hand at building E. L. Moore's narrow gauge coaches. That didn't happen, but these chassises seemed just the right thing for this project.

HO scale Kadee couplers - leftovers from my spares box - were used.

It turns out I did at one time make a start on those E. L. Moore coaches. I had built up a Peco kit for one before setting the project aside. This meant I had to do some rather crude chopping on the chassis to replace the kit's couplers with some HO-scale Kadee units. 

Styrene strips were added to restore the deck after chopping the chassis for the couplers.

Super glue was used to stick the couplers to the chassis. You can see in the above photo I had to restore some of the hacked and chopped chassis with styrene strips to restore solidity to the thing. Those pieces are the same thickness as the metal weight that is provided in the kit.


Once all this basic structural work was done the next task was to build up the deck with pieces of styrene. I followed much the same procedure as with last year's trolley project.


This post's lead photo and the one above give you an idea of what the built-up deck looks like. I didn't strictly follow the prototype in the book. My rendition was more driven by scrap styrene I had on hand to build up something that seemed plausible. 


The couplers sit rather low and only about half are gripped by the trolley's couplers. Well, I've taken the flat car for many spins around the track and they don't decouple, so I'll declare the couplers ok even though they are very unprototypical - they work, so I guess that's some sort of prototypicalness :-)

Now it's on to a bench and canopy.