Tuesday, September 13, 2022

Use small to seem large

Use small to seem large: Use small buildings and structures to make a layout's space seem large.

Usage: Use small to seem large was the guiding design principle on Brian's basement sized N-scale layout of the Canadian prairies.

Source: The 'Use small to seem large' design concept, first developed and articulated by John Allen on his Gorre & Daphetid RR, was reported by Earl Cochrane in the October 1955 Railroad Model Craftsman article, Sunset on the old G & D:

I was quite surprised to learn from John that he used small buildings and structures on his pike. He said that his structures were not underscaled, as I at first thought, but rather small in prototype size. By using small structures in this way, it made the layout look larger and gave a better perspective. Large buildings on a small pike look out of place.

Update to 2nd ed., 1999: For a contrasting design philosophy tailored more to urban and suburban settings refer to Art Curren's article, The BTR RR., in the September 1980 issue of Model Railroader. Mr. Curren discusses how to eliminate feelings of brief travel times and short distances on a small layout (in this article the layout measures 5' x 9') by using features like having tightly packed industrial areas separated by treed residential areas butted up against them, lots of non-railroad buildings, tall buildings that block views, a variety of levels, steep grades, and streets that twist and turn in many directions. The net effect being that the layout seems larger than its relatively diminutive footprint would suggest.

Update to 3rd ed., 2019: Selective Compression [alternate] is a variation on the 'Use small to seem large' concept in that the buildings and structures are neither compressed nor underscaled, and are used to manipulate the viewer's perception of the size of the layout's space.

from The Dictionary of Non-Existent Model Railroad Terms, 1st ed., 1959.

Monday, September 12, 2022

A new stake car for the Lands & Forests RR

Left: Unconverted | Right: Converted
I took the stake wagon that had a pair of broken stakes on one end and 'converted' it to a freelanced car for the Loonar Module. I say 'converted' because all I did was add some sign boards, paint the body yellow, the wooden floor a dirty brown, and the chassis a grimy black, and then add some decals - not much of a conversion.

A few days after finishing I was reading through Brick Price's narrow gauge modelling book again, and stumbled across a very similar 'conversion' on page 95. Concerning the gondola in figure 8-24 at the top of the page, Mr. Price had this to say:

It is made in England and is considered N scale, but the body size is perfect and the trucks are even credible for arch bars. It took fifteen minutes to convert the coupler, weather it, and remove the buffers on the end.

Everything old is new again I guess.

Sunday, September 11, 2022

In Search of Ancient Space Hoppers

It's not over here.

Ancient space hopper theorists believe that what we today think of as mere railway hopper cars are in fact chariots of ancient railway space gods. The key to the mystery of the whereabouts of those ancient space hopperists can be found written on freight cars, especially hoppers, in railway yards around the planet. The Havelock yard is an especially potent site, but this investigator has been unable to replicate last year's sighting either of Space Hopper or Son of Space Hopper.

Nor is it here.
One wonders though what sort of railway vehicle is being transported towards Havelock early on a Sunday morning down a remote highway under a shrink wrap cloak? Oversize load indeed.
Who knows what lurks underneath the shrink wrap?

Thursday, September 8, 2022

Pumpkinvine

Pumpkinvine: A relatively small, multi-level track plan that loops and twists and turns from plains to summits and back again.

Usage: Sally's 0-4-0 wasn't powerful enough to haul the four boxcars through Bob's Pumpkinvine layout.

Source: Bill Schopp, in his guise as The Layout Doctor, introduced the term in the May 1953 issue of Railroad Model Craftsman in an article called, naturally enough, Pumpkinvine Layouts:

When it comes to getting a lot of multi-level mountain railroading in a small space in HO gauge, I've yet to find a layout idea that works out better than what I call the Pumpkinvine, exemplified by the three designs here.

In essence, a classic Pumpkinvine track plan is based on a figure-8 with extended looping that climbs up and has at least three levels. The climbs are usually up through mountainous terrain. Mr. Schopp shows that a viable layout can be built in as little space as 4' x 10'. 

Even though multi-level mountain spectacles are easily created with the Pumpkinvine approach, there are drawbacks:

The one big disadvantage is that there is usually very little space for any sort of town, so you have to imagine that they are in that mystic geographic area just off your platform. It is quite difficult, too, to work in many industrial sidings yet have all switches accessible from the front.

The Pumpkinvine is not to be confused with either the omnivagant or spaghetti layout.

from The Dictionary of Non-Existent Model Railroad Terms, 1st ed.,1959.

Wednesday, September 7, 2022

Anti-layout

Anti-layout: A layout whose purpose is to display as many locomotives and cars as possible.

Usage: William's anti-layout held his entire 200 hopper collection.

Source: Bill Schopp first introduced the term in an article, Track Plans for Modelers who hate Layouts, in the October 1958 issue of Railroad Model Craftsman:

...we've departed from the usual and come up with some layouts and percepts with the "anti-layout" car and loco builder in mind. ...

These layouts have had one basic thought: to keep your equipment on the track and off the shelves and out of boxes.

An anti-layout is characterized by having the maximum amount of yard space (possibly including a roundhouse or two) either surrounded by or surrounding a simple loop of track in the smallest possible space that can be accommodated by the modeller's living quarters. 

A good anti-layout design is one that can display every piece of rolling stock in an owner's collection.

Anti-layouts are usually built by modellers whose main interest is building rolling stock.

Mr. Schopp notes these layouts are not necessarily dead-ends:

Most of these ideas can be scenicked and developed into complete railroads in themselves, or into parts of larger railroads.

The anti-layout should not be confused with either the omnivagant or spaghetti layout.

from The Dictionary of Non-Existent Model Railroad Terms, 1st ed., 1959.