I've been thinking about what's causing my mental blocks to creating the Alta Vista TC layout. I've realized: the residential panel didn't seem right with its small island of buildings surrounded by a road; I wanted an ocean / water / beach feature as I had on the LOL; the straight centre panel isn't long enough; the weird orientation of the end panels didn't play out as I had hoped; and I didn't like the name :-)
I removed the residential panel, and it's going to be rebuilt into an end-of-line loop near oceanfront. But, more importantly, I'm going to focus on getting the Neville Park loop scenicked and running to see if it can be saved, or if it should also be changed, which would basically mean scrapping the layout if I can't get it looking and running to my satisfaction. Other issues I'll put on the back burner until I sort out the Neville Park loop.
Ok, I have tentatively sorted out a new layout name: The Ocean Park Loop, since the track forms a loop that has a park at one end (Neville Park and its turnaround) and an ocean at the other (TBD on the name at this end).
Monday, September 16, 2019
Sunday, September 15, 2019
Light rail? Subway? Streetcar?
This is admittedly a nerdy topic, but indulge me for a few minutes.
The O-Train Confederation Line is referred to as a light rail system, and I guess it is within the common use of the term. But I've been wondering if it's actually a 'light rail' / subway / streetcar hybrid - even wikipedia notes that it's difficult to pin down an exact definition of what constitutes a light rail system. That is certainly true of the Confederation Line.
On the 'light rail' side of things, The Confederation Line has many segments as per the tight definition in Wikipedia: light rail operates primarily along exclusive rights-of-way and uses either individual tramcars or multiple units coupled to form a train that is lower capacity and lower speed than a long heavy-rail passenger train or metro system. But, there's a subway side too: there's 2.5 km of underground track downtown servicing the equally underground Lyon, Parliament, and Rideau stations.
And you may recall from an earlier post that the trains themselves, the Alstom Citadis Spirits, are basically very large streetcars, even though they aren't running on the streets of Ottawa. Interestingly, even Alstom's own site refers to the cars used on the Confederation Line as streetcars.
Does any of this make any difference to day-to-day operations? Likely not. Definitions don't matter much when it comes to designing and building a railway. It's the requirements and costs and such things that need to be paid attention to.
The O-Train Confederation Line is referred to as a light rail system, and I guess it is within the common use of the term. But I've been wondering if it's actually a 'light rail' / subway / streetcar hybrid - even wikipedia notes that it's difficult to pin down an exact definition of what constitutes a light rail system. That is certainly true of the Confederation Line.
On the 'light rail' side of things, The Confederation Line has many segments as per the tight definition in Wikipedia: light rail operates primarily along exclusive rights-of-way and uses either individual tramcars or multiple units coupled to form a train that is lower capacity and lower speed than a long heavy-rail passenger train or metro system. But, there's a subway side too: there's 2.5 km of underground track downtown servicing the equally underground Lyon, Parliament, and Rideau stations.
![]() |
| The last line refers to the Confederation trains as streetcars: snapped 19 Sept '19 |
And you may recall from an earlier post that the trains themselves, the Alstom Citadis Spirits, are basically very large streetcars, even though they aren't running on the streets of Ottawa. Interestingly, even Alstom's own site refers to the cars used on the Confederation Line as streetcars.
Does any of this make any difference to day-to-day operations? Likely not. Definitions don't matter much when it comes to designing and building a railway. It's the requirements and costs and such things that need to be paid attention to.
Saturday, September 14, 2019
Opening Day of OCTranspo's Confederation Line
Today was the first day of operation of OCTranspo's Confederation Line, and this morning's inaugural ceremonies and ride were pulled off without a hitch. The event was fun and flawless, and it appeared a good time was had by all.
A little background. Ottawa hasn't had a electric railway to provide its citizens with urban transportation since it closed down its streetcar system in May 1959. Up until then it had an urban street railway - first horse powered and then electric - that had been in continuous operation since the summer of 1870. In 2001 a diesel powered light rail system, the Trillium Line, was introduced by OCTranspo, and today it forms the north-south branch of the O-Train system, with the fully electric Confederation Line providing east-west transportation. The Trillium and Confederation Lines come together at the Bayview station. Neither of these lines run in the street, but on their own dedicated track.
The event got started around 10:15 with speeches, recognition, and congratulations to all governmental organizations, aboriginal peoples, contractors, builders, construction workers, and city staff who made the Confederation Line a reality. This is a project that broke ground in 2013 and finished all up system testing just a few weeks ago. It's been the largest project undertaken so far in the city's history, and it's had its share of problems, one of which was being well over a year late.
After the ceremonies it was on to the main event: the inaugural ride from Tunney's Pasture station, where this event was taking place, out to Blair station at the east end, and back again. It was standing room only in the train, and there was maybe around 300 people packing the vehicle - likely a good simulation of rush hour traffic :-)
As I mentioned earlier, the ride down the 12.5 km line and back again was flawless. The train stopped at each station, but didn't open its doors, and after a brief stop was on its way again. By chance I was jammed in a car not too far from Mayor Jim Watson. For a while John Manconi, the general manager of city transportation services, who is basically the head cheese project manager on this project, was standing near the mayor and looking a bit tense. I assume it was because last week he had to explain why a train on the Confederation Line got stuck in a tunnel for several hours one night which, among other things, involved an odd semantic discussion on whether the train was actually stopped as opposed to stuck. However, he didn't need to worry today. The only thing that seemed a little odd to me in an otherwise perfect trip was the train seemed to have a little trouble climbing an uphill grade. I was standing sandwiched between suits and a French language camera crew, so I have no data to substantiate my feeling other than the sense of a little hesitation in the train.
If you're a regular reader of 30 Squares you know the main topic here is model building. And a version of model building that leans towards aesthetics and story telling - the romance of the rails. However, the purpose of the O-Train isn't that, but the more pragmatic goal of providing safe, reliable, and useful service to everyone in Ottawa. It's an engineered system that has to perform over the days, months, and years ahead.
The Confederation Line opened to all riders at 2pm today, is open for regular Sunday hours tomorrow, and sees its first day of busy commuters and rush hour service on Monday. It's what's ahead that will tell the Confederation Line's story, but today was a great beginning.
Postscript: Dave told me I had to make sure I got whatever swag was being given out at this event. Dave, that's it over there :-) Down in the lower left is my certificate that I rode the inaugural ride in case any proof is needed in the future :-)
![]() |
| Watson & Mulroney unveil the commemorative plaque |
![]() |
| Getting ready to board for the inaugural ride |
After the ceremonies it was on to the main event: the inaugural ride from Tunney's Pasture station, where this event was taking place, out to Blair station at the east end, and back again. It was standing room only in the train, and there was maybe around 300 people packing the vehicle - likely a good simulation of rush hour traffic :-)
As I mentioned earlier, the ride down the 12.5 km line and back again was flawless. The train stopped at each station, but didn't open its doors, and after a brief stop was on its way again. By chance I was jammed in a car not too far from Mayor Jim Watson. For a while John Manconi, the general manager of city transportation services, who is basically the head cheese project manager on this project, was standing near the mayor and looking a bit tense. I assume it was because last week he had to explain why a train on the Confederation Line got stuck in a tunnel for several hours one night which, among other things, involved an odd semantic discussion on whether the train was actually stopped as opposed to stuck. However, he didn't need to worry today. The only thing that seemed a little odd to me in an otherwise perfect trip was the train seemed to have a little trouble climbing an uphill grade. I was standing sandwiched between suits and a French language camera crew, so I have no data to substantiate my feeling other than the sense of a little hesitation in the train.
![]() |
| John Manconi, on far left, is all similes at the end of trip media scrum |
The Confederation Line opened to all riders at 2pm today, is open for regular Sunday hours tomorrow, and sees its first day of busy commuters and rush hour service on Monday. It's what's ahead that will tell the Confederation Line's story, but today was a great beginning.
Postscript: Dave told me I had to make sure I got whatever swag was being given out at this event. Dave, that's it over there :-) Down in the lower left is my certificate that I rode the inaugural ride in case any proof is needed in the future :-)
Wednesday, September 11, 2019
Word on the street, er, at the bus shelter
The OTrain Confederation Line is still 'on track' for opening on Saturday - well, if the bus shelters are anything to go by :-)
Tuesday, September 10, 2019
Thinking about the Alta Vista TC
Work on the Alta Vista TC has been stalled for a very long time. Everyday life has made its demands of course, but that doesn't account for the entire work stoppage. I think the layout isn't up-to-scratch in the simple pleasures department
Although the old Lost Ocean Line wasn't a layout in the standard sense of the word, it was a lot of fun to build and tinker with. And it was also a good place to stage photos.
The AVTC was never meant to be an operational or classical setup. It was just a place to loop streetcars from time-to-time, stage photos, and let me shuffle buildings around. I need to think about what's missing before I get going on a round of construction in preparation for Christmas.
Although the old Lost Ocean Line wasn't a layout in the standard sense of the word, it was a lot of fun to build and tinker with. And it was also a good place to stage photos.
The AVTC was never meant to be an operational or classical setup. It was just a place to loop streetcars from time-to-time, stage photos, and let me shuffle buildings around. I need to think about what's missing before I get going on a round of construction in preparation for Christmas.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)












