Sunday, July 31, 2022
Riding the Budd RDC from Sudbury to White River
Saturday, July 30, 2022
On the mystery of computing area with a balance
![]() |
| My dustcover-less copy of the 1960 classic, The Scientific American Book of Projects for the Amateur Scientist |
Imagine that we have drawn a simple closed curve on a sheet of writing paper. (Simple means that the curve does not cross itself.) This curve marks out an area on our paper. How many ways can you think of to find this area?
...
I saw a very clever (and most significant) solution to this problem at a model-airplane meet some years ago. The contest rules required that the models have a fuselage whose cross-sectional area was not less than a certain minimum. This area was easy to check in the good old days when all the models had rectangular cross sections, but with the advent of more streamlined shapes the judges began to have trouble making sure the rules were being followed.
They finally decided to find the required area by first having an accurate drawing of it, and then cutting out the drawing and weighing it. Since the weight per unit area of the paper was known, the area of the cut-out drawing was easy to obtain. Now this solution to the area problem is a splendid example of applied integral calculus. It is a little surprising, then, that people who have actually studied calculus will laugh at the method, or dismiss it as impractical. Yet when an accurate balance or scale is at hand it is the quickest way to determine area.
F. W. Niedenfuhr, Professor of Engineering Mechanics at Ohio State University, from The Pleasures of Mathematics in C. L. Strong's The Scientific American Book of Projects for the Amateur Scientist, 1960. Mr. Strong notes this about Prof. Niedenfuhr's chapter in the table of contents, "The amateur scientist is lured into an encounter with integral calculus." Come for the model airplanes, stay for the integral calculus :-)
Tuesday, July 26, 2022
Some backyard railroad drama
I took Paul's advice and tried placing the layout up high and shooting up into the sky. I had some backlighting issues, but things are looking better. Clearly more practice is needed.
Sunday, July 24, 2022
When exhibit becomes layout
In August 1987 I was to lucky to get to visit the Exploratorium in San Francisco’s Palace of Fine Arts. For a souvenir I bought a copy of the pamphlet, Working Prototypes: Exhibit Design at the Exploratorium. As I was reading the book again I wondered what I might learn if I replaced the word ‘exhibit’ with ‘layout’ in the list of exhibit development principles and characteristics that appears in the conclusion. Here’s what I get:
1. Basic research - just plain tinkering around with something for the fun of it - is an essential part of the layout development process.
2. Layouts are designed and developed by people who are interested in the phenomenon to be displayed.
3. To some extent, all layouts are collaborative: many people make suggestions and contribute ideas.
4. The first stage of layout design is the construction of a full-scale working prototype.
5. Layout builders are responsive to comments from visitors and staff, testing layouts at many stages in their development and allowing reactions to shape the layout.
6. Layout builders pay attention to aesthetic nuances, noticing what is fun to do, what is beautiful, what is intriguing.
7. Generally, layout builders try not to restrict a visitor’s choice.
8. Ideally, visitors should be able to see the inner workings of a layout and make discoveries about how the layout works.
9. Most layouts are set up on table tops, so that visitors can gather and use the layout together.
10. Layouts are often constructed of inexpensive materials, scrap, and found objects (or junk).
I can’t say that every item makes sense for a layout, but that’s not the point, which is just to stir the brain up a bit.
I found what seems like an addendum to item 8) noted in K. C. Coles’ 2009 book, Something Incredibly Wonderful Happens: Frank Oppenheimer and the World He Made Up, quite interesting:
Anything involving computers was likely to be rejected out of hand. “There’s nothing a computer can do that I want done,” Frank said. Everything a computer did was a simulation, and therefore not sufficiently transparent - or even “honest” - by Frank’s lights. You couldn’t see what was going on inside the box. Besides, he thought computers were both passive and addictive. And new technology - as he learned at Los Alamos - could all too easily entrap.
Thursday, July 21, 2022
Brick Price's Modeling Narrow-Gauge Railroads
![]() |
| MN-GR from 1984 | How to go T&TWM from 1982 |
A major difficulty in modeling realistic structures from kits is to produce an original design. Most of the dozens of building kits on the market have already appeared in hundreds of photographs in one book or another. It makes no difference how these buildings are placed on a layout or what colors that are painted. If the buildings are from the same kit, they will always look alike unless they are heavily modified. This problem is unique to structures. You expect to see thousands of almost-identical boxcars, but you don't expect to see more than one of Dale's Dingies. Ironically, most model railroaders tend to purchase as many different freight cars as possible, yet they buy the same structures that appear on other model railroads and build them just the way they come out of the box.
Brick Price on Structure Conversions; Modeling Narrow-Gauge Railroads, 1984.
Being curious about the work of Brick Price recently prompted me to buy a copy of his 1984 book on narrow gauge model railroading. It strikes me as something of an odd book, and it leaves me wondering if it was given a rigorous editing prior to publication. It seems like a book for someone who has a bit of familiarity with model railroading and still has large gaps in their general modelling and model railroading knowledge, but might be interested in taking up narrow gauge model railroading. So, there is a lot of general modeling and model railroading material, which at times leaves me thinking the narrow gauge material is a bit thin.
Although, I particularly liked the somewhat misnamed Cross-Kitting chapter. It's not a chapter on the general techniques of kitbashing, or cross-kitting to use the author's term, but an excellent summary on how to kitbash HO scale narrow gauge rolling stock and locos circa the late '70s and early '80s. Lots of interesting examples are shown, and I think the information is still quite applicable today. I found the Scratchbuilding chapter the oddest as it concentrates on providing very general overviews of woodcarving, making rubber molds, lost wax casting, resin casting, metal die-casting, and vacuum forming plastic, which are all rather advanced, professional level scratchbuilding techniques. There isn't anything in the chapter about traditional hobbyist oriented scratchbuilding methods like building from styrene stock or cardboard. Maybe I shouldn't be surprised as Mr. Price was a professional modeller.
![]() |
| A modified Revell Engine House; Compare to Jack O'Vall's |
Yes, I know, my review is around 40 years too late :-) So, what's the big deal? None actually. With these old books I don't look at them as they were intended when they were published. I wouldn't use Modeling Narrow-Gauge Railroads as a guide to building a serious narrow gauge layout today, but look at it as a compendium and record of some of Brick Price's work and thoughts in the area, which are excellent and inspiring, although it would have been nice if the book had some pictures of his layout.




